Jump to content

Why do shot-shells [still] have rims?


Recommended Posts

Random thought.

 

I know way back in the day, all sealed cartridges had rims, I think even center-fire rounds. Than at some point (when was that btw?) they lost their rims and went with what we have today (not sure if the design has a specific name). But it seems like .22LR and shot shells kept the rims. Why? When the industry was converting over to rimless, they didn't they hop aboard. Imagine what ridiculous awesome guns we'd have nowadays if .22LR and shot shells weren't rimmed. What does this hold for the future? It seems like its too late to change now. Will shot-shells and .22 ever loose their rims?

Link to post
Share on other sites

Break action shotguns wouldnt work well otherwise.

 

Sure they would. A different extraction claw/design is all that would be needed, atleast on self ejecting models.

 

I'm curious how you head space a plastic hull without a rim? You can't head space off the brass because of high and low bases.

Link to post
Share on other sites

+1 for what mulletman said. Rimless cartridges headspace on the shoulder or case mouth, not very practical for a shotshell and would not allow you to use multiple shell sizes in one chamber (i.e., 2", 2-3/4" and 3" in a 3" chamber). It's been working well for a couple hundred years and there is no practical or economical advantage to changing it.

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites

Well, since a .22LR is a rimfire I doubt it will ever be rimless. Look into how a rimfire works. There is a company that has been working on a rimless 12g hull, but it would only work with their gun. The only benefit I see would be reducing feed problems in stacked magazines, but I think Mike found a way around that with his double stack.

xacex

Link to post
Share on other sites

In the late 19th century most if not all ammunition had rims such as this .303 British - which was centerfire.

 

.303ammunition.jpeg

 

then at some point they dropped the whole rim idea and went with what we know today, where the rim doesn't extend past the overall diameter:

 

308_Winchester.jpg

 

why, since every other round in the world went down this road, did the .22 not follow suite way back then? I get how now its way too late to change, but that doesn't explains why it wasn't corrected.

 

The same goes for the brass base of shot shells. they COULD have chosen to design the base where the rim doesn't protrude. Why didnt they? Obviously, had they done that, the extraction methods would have been totally different over the years.

 

If shot shells and .22 didn't have protruding rims, the packaging of rounds in a magazine (box or otherwise) would be way more efficient yielding higher capacities in smaller configurations. Isn't that the Holy Grail of magazines?

 

the head spacing aspect of shot shells is a compelling one and maybe the reason why they left the rims, I guess that makes sense. But I still see no reason why .22 remained rimfire.

Edited by AtlSaiga
Link to post
Share on other sites

The 22lr would need a complete redesign to function as a rimless cartridge. The bullet is a heeled type which is the same diameter as the case. The case would have to be larger in diameter to provide for headspacing. Since the firing pin crushes the case to set off the primer, designing a rimless case would be difficult. It would have to be thick enough to allow for proper extraction and soft enough for the firing pin to crush.

 

The only real advantage is that the mags could be produced easier as a rimmed case is harder to get to feed from a box type mag.

 

Concerning the shotshells, a point to headspace on is still needed. Unless you could somehow make the extractor headspace the case, this will be difficult. A magnum type belt could be used but I dont see much advantage to that.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Plus, the sheer number of weapons in circulation means a HUGE market for the current rimmed design, in both cases. Sales volume keeps it alive and well.

 

The 45-70 is still in production for the same reason.

 

eta: There are centerfire 22s.... 218 Bee, 222 Remington, 22 Swift, etc, ad infinitum, ad nauseum.

Edited by patriot
Link to post
Share on other sites

The experimental H&K CAW had a belted case that was semi rimless. It was probably head spaced from the belt.

 

In theory one could make their own rimless shotgun shells using .50BMG cases expanded out to full case diameter.. You would of course be stuck with a single length of shell since you must head space off the front.

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites

A 12 gauge "Auto" would be a great idea for S12s and the like. It could've done if supported by the right people, the main problem is getting guns built that would fire it. Exotic rifles rounds are possible because of the standard rim and chamber style of modern rifles, there is no 12 gauge "Auto" style shotgun (that would cycle this new round), yet but that would be pretty cool. Imagine the magazine designs that would be made possible.

 

This would be very expensive at first and very few people would shell out big bucks for it without much advantage. The 338 Lapua Mag comes to mind, this is successful because there are people willing to pay a lot of money for the added capability but a rimless shotgun isn't going to have the same advantage. Just look around here at all the effort put into firing the cheapest, crap shells, this crowd isn't going to pay a premium for this.

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites

There are bazillions of 12 ga shotguns out there, and they last for years and years. The market for a rimless shotgun shell would be whatever number of new guns you could sell = a formula for economic suicide! A rimless .22 rimfire is a brainless idea the whole point of the rimfire is that it can be made CHEAPLY!

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 2 weeks later...

If you had a rimless 12 gauge you would have to shoot the same ammo out of the gun.If you bought a gun to shoot high brass 3" buckshot then you couldn't use cheaper 2 3/4 low brass.The rim is the only thing that head spaces the gun on a shotty.Without the rim you would have to head space off the front of the brass cup.You couldn't head space off the front of the plastic shell since it is not rigid and changes when fired.That is why we still have modern made rimmed calibers.22 in all the flavors and now the 17HMR and 17HM2.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
  • Chatbox

    Load More
    You don't have permission to chat.
×
×
  • Create New...