I had the same problem the first time I used the retainer plate. It must of taken me 45 minutes to get it installed. You might want to check for any burrs on the plate where it goes over the axis pins, just in case. I found it helpful to file a shallow bevel on the end of the safety where it goes into the left side of the receiver. That's what I did and it made it easier to insert the safety into the receiver. Good luck. Believe me, I feel your pain, LOL! BTW, mine is an S-12, but it looks like the fitment is the same.