Either shotgun would primarily be used as a home defense shotgun. Although I could see using it for three gun matches later on down the line. I liked the Benelli because it is supposedly very reliable, has an 18" barrel, comes with a Picatinny rail, has an eight round capability (with extension tube), and well it's a Benelli
The Saiga caught my eye because of the ability to customize it, supposedly very reliable, also has the capability of hold eight (or even more) rounds.
Basically I went the most reliable semi auto shotgun on the market. The higher capacity the better, and I wo